Dr. Amy Fothergill, MD
Internal Medicine*
15+ years of experience
Dr. Amy Fothergill, MD is an internist in Madison, WI and has over 15 years of experience in the medical field. She graduated from Mayo Clinic Alix School of Medicine in 2009. She is affiliated with medical facilities such as UnityPoint Health-Meriter and University Hospital. She is not accepting new patients.
3.5 Star Rating
Based on 18 reviews 3.5 Star Rating (18 reviews)
Practice
4410 Regent St Madison, WI 53705Telehealth available
At a Glance
- Area of Expertise
- Friendly Staff
- Offers TelehealthThis doctor offers telehealth appointments. Call the office to schedule an appointment.
- Practices at Top Hospital
ADVERTISEMENT
Save money with free prescription discounts
Get your prescription for as low as $4 with our free coupons or discount card, usable at over 64,000 participating pharmacies.
Get your prescription for as low as $4 with our free coupons or discount card, usable at over 64,000 participating pharmacies.
Optum Perks and Healthgrades are subsidiaries of RVO Health.
Experience Check
Search for experience in a specific area
Insurance Check
Search for your insurance carrier and choose your plan type
Dr. Fothergill's Reviews
Likelihood to recommend Dr. Fothergill
3.5
18 ratings, 17 with a written review
| 5 star | 61% | 61% |
| 4 star | 0% | 0% |
| 3 star | 0% | 0% |
| 2 star | 6% | 6% |
| 1 star | 33% | 33% |
Your trust is our top concern.
We strive to keep reviews honest, trustworthy, and fair.Doctors can not pay for good reviews, nor can they pay to have negative reviews removed.
We monitor all reviews to ensure they comply with our guidelines and don’t include personal information, profanity, libel, defamation, harassment, obscenity or fraud.
Any reviews that are deemed fraudulent or violate our guidelines will be removed immediately.
All reviews are confirmed and audited before publication, and community members have the ability to flag inappropriate content for further review by our team.
Outstanding, caring PCP
What went well
- I felt respected
- Appointment scheduling
- Listened & answered questions
- Explained conditions well
- Staff friendliness
- Trusted the provider's decisions
- Wait times
What could be improved
No results
2 others found this helpful
Helpful
MadisonBadger – Sep 18, 2024
Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Fothergill?
I was excited to begin care with dr. Fothergill years ago and I’m not sure what took so long to write this but was really compelled to do so after a handful of visits with seriously underwhelming care. She’s very by the book and you don’t feel comfortable to state your concerns without visible speculation. She has made me feel there’s something wrong with my approach of simply listening to my body and looking for advice. If you want the most basic care for everyday needs, she’s fine. Otherwise cold and distant, Have left on every occasion awkwardly feeling as though I wasted a copay and wanting a second opinion. Scheduling with the clinic is a nightmare and intake staff is rude and aloof.
What went well
No results
What could be improved
- Office environment
- Appointment was rushed
- Didn't trust the provider's decisions
8 others found this helpful
Helpful
Oct 01, 2021
Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Fothergill?
Dr. Fothergill is the best doctor I've ever had. She is caring, thoughtful, extremely knowledgable, isn't patronizing, and I always leave feeling I got quality care from her and her team.
What went well
- Listened & answered questions
- Explained conditions well
- Staff friendliness
- Appointment wasn't rushed
- Trusted the provider's decisions
What could be improved
No results
1 other person found this helpful
Helpful
Jul 19, 2021
Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Fothergill?
My very first visit with her NP and I'm called a liar. When I made my lab appt, I really did ask if it was a fasting lab and she told me based on the order it was not. But the NP called me a liar when she said, "I doubt that." The NP also wasted my time and money too. If this is acceptable to you, then I should find another doctor.
What went well
No results
What could be improved
- Office environment
- Didn't explain conditions well
- Staff wasn't friendly
- Appointment was rushed
- Didn't trust the provider's decisions
1 other person found this helpful
Helpful
Chance – Feb 24, 2021
Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Fothergill?
I have been seeing Dr.Fothergill for over 3 years. She is very good. She has always been very proactive and responsive to my concerns. She is a kind, caring person. I would strongly recommend her to anyone.
What went well
- Office environment
- Appointment scheduling
- Listened & answered questions
- Explained conditions well
- Staff friendliness
- Appointment wasn't rushed
- Trusted the provider's decisions
- Wait times
What could be improved
No results
1 other person found this helpful
Helpful
Ginger Papageorge – Feb 14, 2021
Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Fothergill?
Dr. Fothergill has been my internist for almost 5 years now, thankfully. She is exceptionally: smart, knowledgeable, caring and a true partner in my health. I never feel rushed and Dr. Fothergill patiently listens and thoroughly examines what is relevant and needed without overmedicating or pushing for unnecessary procedures and/or tests - a rare gem.
What went well
- Office environment
- Appointment scheduling
- Listened & answered questions
- Explained conditions well
- Staff friendliness
- Appointment wasn't rushed
- Trusted the provider's decisions
What could be improved
No results
1 other person found this helpful
Helpful
Patient Patient – Nov 01, 2020
Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Fothergill?
I have had several complex medical problems, and Dr. Fothergill always takes the time to listen and then comes up with a comprehensive plan. I am an RN, and so I know how to assess MDs. I am very conscientious and patient focused in my practice, and I look for that in a physican.
What went well
- Office environment
- Appointment scheduling
- Listened & answered questions
- Explained conditions well
- Staff friendliness
- Appointment wasn't rushed
- Trusted the provider's decisions
What could be improved
No results
1 other person found this helpful
Helpful
CHRN – Jul 15, 2020
Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Fothergill?
Disappointing. I"m looking for a new Physician but she wont be it after my visit. She didnt make a lot of effort & provided only a very basic exam.
What went well
- Office environment
- Appointment scheduling
- Listened & answered questions
- Explained conditions well
- Staff friendliness
What could be improved
- Appointment was rushed
3 others found this helpful
Helpful
NA – Jan 04, 2020
Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Fothergill?
Made me feel like I was exaggerating on what was going on with me. wasted my time and money because she did not fill my concerns
What went well
- Office environment
- Staff friendliness
What could be improved
- Didn't listen or answer questions
- Didn't explain conditions well
- Appointment was rushed
- Didn't trust the provider's decisions
3 others found this helpful
Helpful
Dec 31, 2019
Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Fothergill?
I have been a patient, of Dr. Fothergill's, for almost *five* years. Quite simply, she is, by far, the *best* PCP i have ever had -- it's *not* even close ... I have found Dr. Fothergill to be *fully* open, to my ideas and input, re the/my course of treatment. I absolutely *cannot* recommend her highly enough -- she is *that* good! Michael K. Middleton Wisco
What went well
- Office environment
- Appointment scheduling
- Listened & answered questions
- Explained conditions well
- Staff friendliness
- Appointment wasn't rushed
- Trusted the provider's decisions
What could be improved
No results
Helpful
Michael – Dec 14, 2019
Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Fothergill?
My husband and I love Dr Fothergill! She has been incredibly helpful, patient and thorough in diagnosing and treating our medical issues. She truly listens and is nonjudgmental. She is there to help you make the best decisions for your health and we've never felt rushed.
What went well
- Office environment
- Appointment scheduling
- Listened & answered questions
- Explained conditions well
- Staff friendliness
- Appointment wasn't rushed
- Trusted the provider's decisions
- Wait times
What could be improved
No results
2 others found this helpful
Helpful
Sep 04, 2019
Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Fothergill?
Dr. Fothergill was very helpful! Addressed all of my concerns!
What went well
No results
What could be improved
No results
Helpful
May 01, 2019
Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Fothergill?
I have found Dr. Fothergill to be very knowledgeable and compassionate. As a pharmacist, also healthcare professional, I've been very happy with the care and attention I have received.
What went well
No results
What could be improved
No results
1 other person found this helpful
Helpful
Mar 29, 2019
Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Fothergill?
Totally agree with 2 other reviewers. She ignored years of recommendations and medication history from the doctor she replaced, Dr. Frances Ryan. She has refused to renew 2 of my scripts that are hormonal in nature and decreased my script for another from 90 days to 30 day refills. She refused to listen to me. I told her this costs much more money and running around. She treats her patients with a cookie cutter approach not as individuals. Love Dr. Ryan, leaving Dr. Fothergill.
What went well
- Wait times
What could be improved
- Difficult to schedule appointment
- Didn't listen or answer questions
- Didn't explain conditions well
- Appointment was rushed
- Didn't trust the provider's decisions
6 others found this helpful
Helpful
WI – Dec 18, 2018
Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Fothergill?
I had the same experience, great at first, but - was labled as "depressed" since I told her Lyrica made me feel very weird and not like myself, and I knew that could be a side-effect of the medication. But that was it, from then on, everything was due to "depression". That said, for back pain, hot flashes, you name it - she kept trying to prescribe low-dose anti-depressants! She loves to Rx amitriptaline. Not sure what hours she keeps, but is never in, which is frustrating.
What went well
No results
What could be improved
- Office environment
- Difficult to schedule appointment
- Didn't listen or answer questions
- Didn't explain conditions well
- Staff wasn't friendly
- Appointment was rushed
- Didn't trust the provider's decisions
- Long wait times
5 others found this helpful
Helpful
Cross Plains – Jan 08, 2018
Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Fothergill?
Pleasant bedside manner and excellent clinician. Has been taking care of my aging parents with their multiple problems. Always warm and conscientious toward her patients and take time to address their many issues. She always follows up with lab reports, x-rays etc. Grateful to her and her staff.
What went well
- Office environment
- Appointment scheduling
- Listened & answered questions
- Explained conditions well
- Staff friendliness
- Appointment wasn't rushed
- Trusted the provider's decisions
- Wait times
What could be improved
No results
7 others found this helpful
Helpful
HS in Madison WI – Oct 23, 2016
Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Fothergill?
Did not listen to me at all
Disregarded all prior information and removed diagnosis
Had her own preconceived notions about my issue and did not even talk to me
Simply saw one thing in my file and based all decision based on one thing, not entire file
Worst MD ever
What went well
- Office environment
- Appointment scheduling
- Staff friendliness
- Wait times
What could be improved
- Didn't listen or answer questions
- Didn't explain conditions well
- Appointment was rushed
- Didn't trust the provider's decisions
16 others found this helpful
Helpful
H M in Madison, WI – Oct 10, 2016
Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Fothergill?
Leave a review
How was your experience with Dr. Fothergill?Overall Patient Satisfaction
18responses
Likelihood of recommending Dr. Fothergill to family and friends is 3.5 out of 5
About Me
care philosophy
As a specialist in Internal Medicine, I hold a firm belief in the benefit of long-term doctor-patient relationships. My practice allows me to establish relationships through preventive care and also follow patients in the hospital as well, providing true continuity of care.biography
Health Care PartnershipDr. Fothergill is a board-certified specialist in Internal Medicine who believes that communication and trust are key to her relationships with patients. "I like that my patients are able to talk...read more
Internal Medicine
*Healthgrades does not verify qualifications for medical specialties. Please verify your provider's specialty and qualifications directly with your provider and applicable medical board.
University Of Wisconsin Hospitals And Clinics
Residency Hospital, 2013University Of Wisconsin Hospital And Clinics
Internship Hospital, 2010Mayo Clinic Alix School Of Medicine
Medical School, 2009Masters Of Public Health
2008Gustavus Adolphus College
Undergraduate School, 2004
American Board of Medical Specialties®
American Board of Internal Medicine®
-
Internal Medicine
For detailed information about any of the below board actions, please search for the provider's records on the linked state licensing board or the Federation of State Medical Boards. To learn more about the difference between these sources, please refer to our FAQs.
Healthgrades has not received any data indicating a board action exists for this provider.
Healthgrades receives board action history for physicians and physician assistants. The information displayed here is sourced from independent information providers, such as state board websites, and may not be the most up-to-date information. Healthgrades makes no representations with respect to the accuracy of any information provided here and assumes no responsibility or liability for such information.
Learn more about medical license public record checkFocus on Brain Health
Locations
Practice
Affiliated Hospitals
- Recipient of 18
hospital awardsView all awardsOutstanding Patient Experience Award™ (2024, 2023, 2022)
Top in the nation for overall patient experience based on nine measures related to doctor and nurse communication, hospital cleanliness and noise levels, and medication and post-discharge care instructions
View all patient feedbackHow patients felt about the care they received at this hospital.
90%Patients said they were given information about recovering at home6% higher than the national average
81%Patients said that nurses always listened to them and explained things well6% higher than the national average
- Recipient of 2
hospital awardsView all awardsOutstanding Patient Experience Award™ (2023, 2022)
Top in the nation for overall patient experience based on nine measures related to doctor and nurse communication, hospital cleanliness and noise levels, and medication and post-discharge care instructions
View all patient feedbackHow patients felt about the care they received at this hospital.
90%Patients said they were given information about recovering at home2% higher than the national average
86%Patients said their room and bathroom were always kept clean9% higher than the national average
- Recipient of 20
hospital awardsView all awardsOutstanding Patient Experience Award™ (2024, 2023, 2022)
Top in the nation for overall patient experience based on nine measures related to doctor and nurse communication, hospital cleanliness and noise levels, and medication and post-discharge care instructions
View all patient feedbackHow patients felt about the care they received at this hospital.
87%Patients said they were given information about recovering at home3% higher than the national average
80%Patients said that nurses always listened to them and explained things well5% higher than the national average
Learn more about how Healthgrades measures Hospital Quality
Compare Providers
Providers shown based on Dr. Fothergill's location and specialty. Show more Internal Medicine Doctors.