background
background
Dr. Jeremy Mathis, DO

Dr. Jeremy Mathis, DO

Orthopedic Surgery*

Dr. Jeremy Mathis, DO is an orthopedic surgeon in Columbus, OH. Dr. Mathis has extensive experience in Knee & Lower Limb Surgery. He is affiliated with medical facilities such as Mount Carmel New Albany Surgical Hospital and Mercy Health-St. Rita's Medical Center. He is accepting new patients.

4.8 Star Rating
Based on 101 reviews 4.8 Star Rating (101 reviews)

Practice

1313 Olentangy River Rd Columbus, OH 43212

Make an Appointment

Hospital Highlight

Dr. Mathis is affiliated with Oklahoma Heart Hospital South Oklahoma City, a highly rated hospital.

At a Glance

  • Area of Expertise
    Dr. Mathis specializes in the area of Orthopedic Surgery. See board certifications
  • Explains Conditions Well
    Patients said this doctor explains conditions well. See reviews
  • Practices at Top Hospital
    America’s 100 Best Hospitals for Joint Replacement Award™ See hospitals
  • Hospital Satisfaction
    Patients said they were highly satisfied at this doctor's hospital. See hospitals
ADVERTISEMENT

Save up to 80% on prescriptions

Optum Perks and Healthgrades are subsidiaries of RVO Health.

Experience Check

Search for experience in a specific area

Insurance Check

Search for your insurance carrier and choose your plan type

Dr. Mathis' Reviews

Likelihood to recommend Dr. Mathis

4.8
101 ratings, 35 with a written review
5 star
92%
92%
4 star
5%
5%
3 star
0%
0%
2 star
1%
1%
1 star
2%
2%

Your trust is our top concern.

We strive to keep reviews honest, trustworthy, and fair.

Doctors can not pay for good reviews, nor can they pay to have negative reviews removed.

We monitor all reviews to ensure they comply with our guidelines and don’t include personal information, profanity, libel, defamation, harassment, obscenity or fraud.

Any reviews that are deemed fraudulent or violate our guidelines will be removed immediately.

All reviews are confirmed and audited before publication, and community members have the ability to flag inappropriate content for further review by our team.

My Visit
From the first time I came to see you about my knees I was happy with everything you done for me and the same thing with my last visit but if I decide to have the surgery I was hoping it was going to be you doing it for me but I am sure you have put me in good hands with the other doctor thank you
What went well
  • I felt respected
  • Appointment scheduling
  • Listened & answered questions
  • Explained conditions well
  • Staff friendliness
  • Appointment wasn't rushed
  • Trusted the provider's decisions
  • Wait times
What could be improved
No results
Helpful
Sharon McDonald – Mar 07, 2025
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Mathis?
Surgical Opinion
I saw Dr. Mathis to get a surgical opinion on a knee issue. He was very attentive, answered all my questions and gave me his recommended course of action.
What went well
  • I felt respected
  • Appointment scheduling
  • Listened & answered questions
  • Explained conditions well
  • Staff friendliness
  • Appointment wasn't rushed
  • Trusted the provider's decisions
  • Wait times
What could be improved
No results
Helpful
Dec 29, 2024
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Mathis?
Awesome Doctor
Dr. Mathis has been our doctor for over 15 years. He has treated my husband and myself for shoulders and knees. He is great at what he does, very personable, and makes you feel like you are family. We love Dr. Mathis.
What went well
  • I felt respected
  • Appointment scheduling
  • Listened & answered questions
  • Explained conditions well
  • Staff friendliness
  • Appointment wasn't rushed
  • Trusted the provider's decisions
  • Wait times
What could be improved
No results
Helpful
The Clarks – Nov 07, 2024
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Mathis?
Great experience meeting Dr. Mathis.
Very personable, kind and explained my injury so I understood. Put me at ease, about the meniscus tear and the surgery. So glad I found Dr. Mathis!
What went well
  • I felt respected
  • Appointment scheduling
  • Listened & answered questions
  • Explained conditions well
  • Staff friendliness
  • Appointment wasn't rushed
  • Trusted the provider's decisions
  • Wait times
What could be improved
No results
Helpful
Sheri Frazier – Aug 22, 2024
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Mathis?
A great experience!!!
This was my first visit with Dr. Mathis, and I was impressed with his knowledge and approach to my issues. I feel confident in my choice to work with him.
What went well
  • I felt respected
  • Appointment scheduling
  • Listened & answered questions
  • Explained conditions well
  • Staff friendliness
  • Appointment wasn't rushed
  • Trusted the provider's decisions
  • Wait times
What could be improved
No results
Helpful
Sandy – Jul 17, 2024
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Mathis?
Excellent knowledge, bedside manner, discussion of my condition and treatment options. I would highly recommend Dr. Mathis to my family and friends for your orthopedic problems
What went well
  • I felt respected
  • Listened & answered questions
  • Explained conditions well
  • Staff friendliness
  • Appointment wasn't rushed
  • Trusted the provider's decisions
What could be improved
No results
1 other person found this helpful
Helpful
Michael Perez – May 23, 2024
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Mathis?
Great Doctor
Dr. Mathis is always so present. He listens and explains everything well.
What went well
  • I felt respected
  • Appointment scheduling
  • Listened & answered questions
  • Explained conditions well
  • Staff friendliness
  • Appointment wasn't rushed
  • Trusted the provider's decisions
  • Wait times
What could be improved
No results
Helpful
Diane – May 23, 2024
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Mathis?
Dr Mathis
Dr. Mathis did not really confirm my first need for feet diagnosis before knee surgery. I am finding that throughout the Orthopedic Practices in Columbus, that if a patient is concerned about another area they will need to have diagnostic testing before a knee replacement surgery, so that PT will be successful, that the only focus is their specialty. The knee replacement. No comment made whatsoever about the patient’s concern on another issue that will affect successful healing. Is it a liability issue? I have found I must manage my own health decisions without any input from the professionals. None have been helpful with the “big picture”. I am sorry the medical profession doesn’t look at the whole person & their concerns. Shallow way to practice medicine.
What went well
  • Appointment scheduling
  • Staff friendliness
  • Appointment wasn't rushed
  • Wait times
What could be improved
  • I didn't feel respected
  • Didn't listen or answer questions
  • Didn't explain conditions well
Helpful
Linda S Timberlake Best – Feb 28, 2024
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Mathis?
Exceptional experience.
My experience with OrthoNeuro was exceptional. I cannot praise my physician, Jeremy Mathis, his staff, Polaris surgery Center, their staff, enough. from the diagnosis to the surgery, I was highly pleased. I was walking post surgery with minimal pain. I was released after my first physical therapy evaluation and told that I did not have to return. I return to work and I’m doing great.I wish I had not put off the procedure as long as I did. I feel great. I have already recommended Jeremy Mathis to others.Thank you
What went well
  • I felt respected
  • Appointment scheduling
  • Listened & answered questions
  • Explained conditions well
  • Staff friendliness
  • Appointment wasn't rushed
  • Trusted the provider's decisions
  • Wait times
What could be improved
No results
Helpful
Jeff Camechis – Sep 17, 2023
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Mathis?
Dr. Mathis is very friendly, personable and knowledgeable. He takes his time with me every visit and explains everything in layman terms. I would highly recommend Dr. Mathis.
What went well
  • I felt respected
  • Appointment scheduling
  • Listened & answered questions
  • Explained conditions well
  • Staff friendliness
  • Appointment wasn't rushed
  • Trusted the provider's decisions
  • Wait times
What could be improved
No results
Helpful
JK – Aug 31, 2023
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Mathis?
Above & Beyond
My injury happened 5 months prior to my visit. It was a “rare injury” and a “rare surgery” was needed. Dr. Mathis took the time to explain EVERYTHING so I knew all of my options going into surgery. Not every doc does that anymore! I knew I had a LONG recovery ahead of me with LOTS of PT as well. Never once did a question go unanswered and I truly felt like I was either a good friend or family from the get go. Amazing experience. Not that I ever want a reason to need his expertise in the future, but I’ll definitely return if needed and I’ll always refer! Honestly, I’ll be sad when I’m fully released!
What went well
  • I felt respected
  • Appointment scheduling
  • Listened & answered questions
  • Explained conditions well
  • Staff friendliness
  • Appointment wasn't rushed
  • Trusted the provider's decisions
  • Wait times
What could be improved
No results
Helpful
Stephanie – Jun 02, 2023
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Mathis?
awesome doctor!
I always have a positive experience with Dr. Mathis. I want to give a special thanks to Dr. Mathis and Stacy Fisher for helping me solve a problem I had recently.
What went well
  • Office environment
  • Appointment scheduling
  • Listened & answered questions
  • Explained conditions well
  • Staff friendliness
  • Appointment wasn't rushed
  • Trusted the provider's decisions
  • Wait times
What could be improved
No results
1 other person found this helpful
Helpful
Miriam – Feb 09, 2023
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Mathis?
I could not have asked for a better experience. Dr. Mathis was friendly, professional and knowledgeable. He put me at ease and I felt completely confident in the top notch service he provided. Thank you Dr. Mathis!
What went well
  • Office environment
  • Appointment scheduling
  • Listened & answered questions
  • Explained conditions well
  • Staff friendliness
  • Appointment wasn't rushed
  • Trusted the provider's decisions
  • Wait times
What could be improved
No results
Helpful
Courtney A Shisler – Dec 15, 2022
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Mathis?
Quick and to the point. Good information.
What went well
  • Office environment
  • Appointment scheduling
  • Listened & answered questions
  • Explained conditions well
  • Staff friendliness
  • Appointment wasn't rushed
  • Trusted the provider's decisions
  • Wait times
What could be improved
No results
Helpful
Oct 26, 2022
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Mathis?
I got an appointment quickly. Was scheduled for surgery within a week. Had the surgery and felt great 10 days later. Hopefully Dr. Mathis kept me from having knee replacement surgery.
What went well
  • Office environment
  • Appointment scheduling
  • Listened & answered questions
  • Explained conditions well
  • Staff friendliness
  • Appointment wasn't rushed
  • Trusted the provider's decisions
  • Wait times
What could be improved
No results
Helpful
Oct 26, 2022
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Mathis?
Knee pain
Dr. Mathis and staff were exceptional in availability, scheduling, and explaining step by step what was going on. Dr.Mathis listened to me, and took so much time explaining in detail what was happening and the different possibilities. He is an advocate for the patient which I appreciate!
What went well
  • Office environment
  • Appointment scheduling
  • Listened & answered questions
  • Explained conditions well
  • Staff friendliness
  • Appointment wasn't rushed
  • Trusted the provider's decisions
  • Wait times
What could be improved
No results
Helpful
Penny – Jun 02, 2022
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Mathis?
My personal Experience with Dr. Mathis
I came to Dr. Mathis with what I thought was a torn rotary cuff. With good news after Dr. Mathis reviewed my M.R.I. it was an injury that just needed Physical therapy and a few shots to ease the pain. I'm still under going physical therapy but with Dr. Mathis leading this, I am feeling better already. He has magical fingers that know exactly where I hurt and is doing a fantastic job at helping me. Thank you Dr. Mathis.
What went well
  • Office environment
  • Appointment scheduling
  • Listened & answered questions
  • Explained conditions well
  • Staff friendliness
  • Appointment wasn't rushed
  • Trusted the provider's decisions
  • Wait times
What could be improved
No results
Helpful
Ronald L Chochard Jr. – May 18, 2022
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Mathis?
Rotator Cuff Repair
I went to see Dr. Mathis about my right Shoulder after a fall & on the 1st visit he immediately became more concerned about my LEFT shoulder which I had injured about 18mo. earlier but thought it was just a bad bruise. It was a complete cuff tear & he attempted to repair my left shoulder but too much time had passed - too much scar tissue, etc. Next concern was my right shoulder which he did successfully repair. Through all that he kept me well informed & took good care of me. I'll recommend him to anyone.
What went well
No results
What could be improved
No results
Helpful
2badwings – Mar 14, 2022
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Mathis?
Excellent
What went well
No results
What could be improved
No results
Helpful
Feb 04, 2022
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Mathis?
What can I say without going into to much detail but I will say Dr Mathis is a wonderful doctor and is very in touch with his patients. He truly cares about his patients and u can sense that every time u come for an office visit . His patients truly are his priority and how there recovery is coming along . You could not be in any better hands for your surgery than in Dr. Mathis And his secretary Monica always makes sure she can get u scheduled what always works for you, this makes the office visits always go smoothly Thank u Monica . Words will never be able Dr.Mathis for how truly I and my family are for all and I mean all the work to keep me going, and get me back !! To then always following up with me and giving me a second chance to get Back to work with my arm& shoulder mobility again , thanks to your magic Hands . I pray that the Lord is always watching over you, and your family and to always continue to bless u with your wisdom for all your surgeries.
What went well
No results
What could be improved
No results
Helpful
Edward camacho – Nov 18, 2021
×Post a ResponseAre you Dr. Mathis?

Leave a review

How was your experience with Dr. Mathis?

About Me

Watch Dr. Mathis' Video

care philosophy

``Whether you are a student-athlete, professional athlete, a weekend warrior, or have never played sports in your life, I am grateful that I can help you return to your pre-injury level of activity.  Call me  for an appointment- let's get you better!``

biography

Dr. Mathis believes in discussing options with his patients to determine the best course of treatment- surgically or not. He volunteers as an Orthopedic Consultant for Dublin Scioto and Dublin Coffman high schools.  Dr. Mathis...read more
  • Orthopedic Surgery

  • Sports Medicine

*Healthgrades does not verify qualifications for medical specialties. Please verify your provider's specialty and qualifications directly with your provider and applicable medical board.

  • Ohio State Sports Medicine

    Fellowship Hospital
  • Memorial Hospital

    Residency Hospital
  • Doctor's Hospital North

    Internship Hospital
  • Ohio University Heritage College Of Osteopathic Medicine

    Medical School
American Osteopathic Association®
American Osteopathic Board of Orthopedic Surgery®
Orthopedic Surgery
For detailed information about any of the below board actions, please search for the provider's records on the linked state licensing board or the Federation of State Medical Boards. To learn more about the difference between these sources, please refer to our FAQs.
Healthgrades has not received any data indicating a board action exists for this provider.
  • International Congress for Joint Reconstruction, Member

Locations

Practice

Orthopedic & Neurological Consultants Inc.1313 Olentangy River Rd Columbus, OH 43212
1
  • Call
  • Fax
  • Hours
    • Mon: 8:00am - 5:00pm
    • Tue: 8:00am - 5:00pm
    • Wed: 8:00am - 5:00pm
    • Thu: 8:00am - 5:00pm
    • Fri: 8:00am - 5:00pm
    • Sat: closed
    • Sun: closed
  • Directions

Practice

Orthopedic & Neurological Consultants Inc6785 Bobcat Way Ste 300 Dublin, OH 43016
2

Practice

Orthopedic & Neurological Consultants Inc.1030 Refugee Rd Ste 180 Pickerington, OH 43147
3
  • Call
  • Fax
  • Hours
    • Mon: 8:00am - 5:00pm
    • Tue: 8:00am - 5:00pm
    • Wed: 8:00am - 5:00pm
    • Thu: 8:00am - 5:00pm
    • Fri: 8:00am - 5:00pm
    • Sat: closed
    • Sun: closed
  • Directions

Practice

Orthopedic & Neurological Consultants Inc.70 S Cleveland Ave Westerville, OH 43081
4
  • Call
  • Fax
  • Hours
    • Mon: 8:00am - 5:00pm
    • Tue: 8:00am - 5:00pm
    • Wed: 8:00am - 5:00pm
    • Thu: 8:00am - 5:00pm
    • Fri: 8:00am - 5:00pm
    • Sat: closed
    • Sun: closed
  • Directions

Affiliated Hospitals

  • Oklahoma Heart Hospital South

    5200 E I 240 Service Rd
    Oklahoma City, OK 73135
    Recipient of 3
    hospital awards

    Outstanding Patient Experience Award™ (2024, 2023, 2022)

    Top in the nation for overall patient experience based on nine measures related to doctor and nurse communication, hospital cleanliness and noise levels, and medication and post-discharge care instructions

    View all awards

    How patients felt about the care they received at this hospital.

    93%
    Patients who gave a rating of 9 or 10

    22% higher than the national average

    93%
    Patients would recommend the hospital to friends and family

    24% higher than the national average

    View all patient feedback
  • Diley Ridge Medical Center

    7911 Diley Rd
    Canal Winchester, OH 43110

    How patients felt about the care they received at this hospital.

    93%
    Patients said they were given information about recovering at home

    6% higher than the national average

    92%
    Patients would recommend the hospital to friends and family

    15% higher than the national average

    View all patient feedback
  • Mount Carmel New Albany Surgical Hospital

    7333 Smiths Mill Rd
    New Albany, OH 43054
    Recipient of 11
    hospital awards

    America’s 100 Best Hospitals for Joint Replacement Award™ (2025, 2024, 2023)

    Superior clinical outcomes in knee and hip replacement

    Patient Safety Excellence Award™ (2025, 2024, 2023)

    Superior clinical outcomes in knee and hip replacement

    View all awards

    How patients felt about the care they received at this hospital.

    90%
    Patients said they were given information about recovering at home

    2% higher than the national average

    86%
    Patients said that nurses always listened to them and explained things well

    4% higher than the national average

    View all patient feedback
Learn more about how Healthgrades measures Hospital Quality